Extended due to popular demand until 16 June | 20% OFF ALL WEDDING RINGS
How many carat engagement ring should you choose?
Engagement rings
Doreen
26 May 2025
Share
How many carats gold should your engagement ring be?
Introduction: finding the perfect balance between carat and craftsmanship
Choosing an engagement ring is one of the most meaningful decisions in your life. But how many carats should a diamond engagement ring be? What does carat really mean in both diamonds and gold? And how do you find the right balance between appearance, durability, and budget?
In this complete guide, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know about diamond carat weight, gold purity, popular ring styles, and expert tips for choosing the right ring. Whether you’re looking for a classic solitaire or a custom-designed piece, this guide will help you choose a carat engagement ring that perfectly reflects your love story.
What does carat mean in diamonds?
When it comes to diamonds, carat refers to weight, not size. One carat equals 200 milligrams. While higher carat diamonds often appear larger, their true visual impact depends on the cut, shape, and proportions. For example, a 1-carat oval diamond can look larger than a 1-carat round diamond because of its elongated shape and surface area.
- Well-cut diamonds sparkle more and may appear larger than heavier, poorly cut stones.
- Popular shapes like oval, marquise, and pear tend to maximise visual size.
- Carat weight is one of the “Four Cs” of diamonds (carat, cut, colour, clarity), all of which influence beauty and value.
In the UK, the average carat size for an engagement ring is around 0.6 carats, but personal style, budget, and lifestyle play an important role in deciding what’s best for you.
What does carat mean in gold, then?
Gold carat (with a “c” in the UK, “karat” in the US) measures the proportion of pure gold in jewellery as a percentage of the total material. These carat levels are common terms used in the jewellery industry to describe gold purity:
- 24 carat = 99.9% pure gold (very soft, rarely used in rings)
- 18 carat = 75% pure gold (luxurious, rich colour)
- 14 carat = 58.5% pure gold (stronger and more durable)
- 9 carat = 37.5% pure gold (affordable, hard-wearing)
The percentage shown for each carat level refers to the proportion of pure gold in the alloy. Gold jewellery is made by mixing gold with other metals to improve durability and strength. The material used in gold jewellery is therefore a combination of gold and other metals, and the raw material must meet certain standards for quality and purity. Gold is a precious metal, valued for its rarity and purity. In many countries, only gold above a certain purity can legally be called gold.
The UK legal minimum for gold jewellery is 9 carat, and each alloy has its own characteristics. Let's break it down:
- 9 carat = 37.5 % pure gold = budget-friendly, durable, less warm in tone
- 14 carat = 58.5 % pure gold = balanced option, popular in everyday wear
- 18 carat = 75 % pure gold = luxurious look, richer yellow colour
- 22 carat = 91.6 % pure gold = rare, soft, mostly used in Asian markets
Whether you choose white gold, yellow gold, or rose gold, the carat level determines the gold purity, not the colour.
Choosing the right carat level for your ring
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer when it comes to carat weight. It depends on your:
- Budget
- Partner’s style – Choose a ring that reflects your partner and the unique relationship you share, ensuring it symbolizes your love and commitment.
- Gold preference and skin sensitivity
- Daily lifestyle and wearability needs
When to choose 14 carat:
- More scratch-resistant
- Suitable for everyday wear
- Ideal budget-friendly option
When to choose 18 carat:
- Offers a richer, warmer hue
- Feels more luxurious and premium
- Popular among those with sensitive skin
Want durability and elegance? Go for 14 carat. Want a statement ring with classic richness? Choose 18 carat.
Popular ring styles and diamond cuts
When choosing an engagement ring, you'll find a wide variety of engagement rings available in different styles and settings to suit every taste.
Your choice of diamond shape greatly affects how the ring looks on the hand:
- Round brilliant: classic sparkle
- Oval: elegant and makes the finger appear longer
- Cushion and princess: modern and feminine
- Emerald and Asscher: sophisticated, vintage vibes with refined craftsmanship
Many jewellers offer a curated collection of engagement rings, allowing you to explore a distinguished selection of high-quality, meticulously crafted designs.
Settings also influence appearance:
- Solitaire: timeless and minimalist
- Three-stone: symbolises past, present, future
- Halo: adds extra sparkle and makes the centre stone appear bigger
Factors affecting the price of your engagement ring
When shopping for an engagement ring, understanding what drives the price can help you make a confident, informed choice. The most significant factor is the carat weight of the diamond—larger diamonds are much rarer and command higher prices, especially when paired with excellent clarity and colour. Diamond experts agree that a well-cut diamond, regardless of carat, will sparkle beautifully and often appear larger than a heavier but poorly cut stone.
The type of metal used for the band also plays a crucial role in the overall cost. Precious metals like pure gold, white gold, rose gold, and platinum are more valuable than other base metals, with platinum and higher carat gold (such as 18 or 24 carat) being especially prized for their purity and durability. The purity of gold, measured in carat or fineness, directly impacts both the value and the appearance of your gold jewellery. The London Bullion Market Association (https://www.lbma.org.uk/) sets strict standards for gold purity, ensuring that gold jewellery meets a legal minimum for quality and authenticity.
The ring’s setting can further influence the price. Classic solitaire settings are often more affordable, while intricate designs like three-stone rings or those featuring additional stones and detailed craftsmanship can increase the cost. Every detail, from the choice of metal to the complexity of the setting, adds to the unique beauty and value of your engagement ring.
Ultimately, the price of an engagement ring is shaped by a combination of carat weight, diamond quality, metal type, purity, and design. By understanding these factors and considering your budget and priorities, you can find a ring that perfectly balances beauty, value, and meaning.
Budgeting for your engagement ring
How much should you spend on an engagement ring? Some still follow the “three-month salary” rule, but today it’s all about personal priorities.
A smart ring buyer considers:
- Carat weight vs. cut quality
- Natural vs. lab-grown diamonds
- Metal options like platinum or white gold
- Added features like certification, engraving, or custom designs
With thoughtful planning, it’s absolutely possible to find a high-quality ring that fits both your taste and your budget.
Working with a jeweller: expert guidance for your perfect ring
Partnering with a reputable jeweller is one of the best ways to ensure your engagement ring is everything you’ve dreamed of. An experienced jeweller brings expert knowledge of diamond shapes—whether you’re drawn to the timeless princess cut, the elegant emerald cut, or another unique style—and can help you select a stone that sparkles beautifully within your budget.
A skilled jeweller will guide you through the nuances of carat weight, clarity, and colour, helping you find a diamond that offers the best combination of brilliance and value. They’ll also advise on the most suitable metal for your lifestyle, whether it’s classic gold, durable platinum, or elegant silver, and explain the differences between 9 carat, 18 carat, and even pure 24 carat gold. Understanding the purity and fineness of the metal is essential, and a trustworthy jeweller will ensure your ring meets the legal minimum standards set by organizations like the London Bullion Market Association.
Customisation is another advantage of working with a jeweller. Whether you envision a classic solitaire, a three-stone setting, or a bespoke design with intricate details, a jeweller can help bring your vision to life, ensuring your engagement ring reflects your unique beauty and personal style.
Beyond aesthetics, a reputable jeweller will educate you about the different metals and alloys used in jewellery, including how base metals can affect durability, wear, and cost. Their expertise ensures that your ring is not only stunning but also crafted to last a lifetime, making it a true symbol of your love and commitment.
By seeking expert guidance, you’ll gain confidence in your choices and enjoy a seamless, enjoyable experience—resulting in an engagement ring that exceeds your expectations in quality, value, and lasting beauty.
Expert tips for choosing a carat engagement ring
Focus on cut quality – sparkle can outweigh size
Choose the carat weight that matches your partner’s lifestyle
Don’t overlook clarity and colour – while flawless diamonds are extremely rare and expensive, they represent the highest standard of clarity and quality
Explore different gold types and alloys
Get advice from reputable jewellers and compare options
Conclusion: a carat ring worth saying "Yes!" to
The carat level on an engagement ring is more than just a number. It’s about balance – between beauty, value, and practicality. Whether you choose a classic 14 carat gold ring with a 0.5ct round diamond, or a bold 18 carat halo ring with a 1.2ct pear-shaped stone, the most important thing is that it tells your story.
With the right knowledge of gold carat, diamond weight, and jewellery quality, you’ll be ready to choose an engagement ring that dazzles for a lifetime.
FAQ: Understanding gold carat in engagement rings
Diamond carat refers to the weight of the diamond (1 carat = 200mg), while gold carat refers to the purity of the gold used in the ring (e.g. 18 carat gold = 75% pure gold).
Gold carat refers to the purity of gold used in jewellery. It indicates how many parts out of 24 are pure gold. For example, 18 carat gold contains 75% pure gold and 25% other metals.
It depends. Higher carat gold (like 18ct) has a richer colour and more pure gold, but it’s also softer. Lower carat gold (like 14ct or 9ct) is more durable and better suited for everyday wear.
- 9ct gold = 37.5% pure gold – affordable and strong
- 14ct gold = 58.5% pure gold – good balance between value and durability
- 18ct gold = 75% pure gold – luxurious appearance, softer feel
Yes. In the UK, 9 carat gold is legally recognised as real gold. It’s commonly used for jewellery and is more budget-friendly than higher carat options.
14ct is ideal for daily wear due to its strength and attractive tone. 18ct offers a richer yellow colour and feels more luxurious. The best choice depends on your lifestyle and budget.
Yes. Higher carat gold (like 18ct) has a warmer, richer hue. Lower carat gold (like 9ct) appears lighter and less yellow because of the higher content of alloy metals.
Absolutely. White gold and rose gold are made by mixing pure gold with different metals, and they are available in various carat levels like 9ct, 14ct and 18ct.
